Thursday, November 19, 2026

The First Moments of Silent Hill 2

 I've been watching the Euro Brady  "Therapist Plays" playthrough of Silent Hill 2's remake, which is a really interesting experience. Silent Hill is the psychological survival horror series, and while I can't comment with any serious authority given that the only entry in the series I've played is this one, I'm given to understand that 2 is the most "psychological" one of the series, setting aside the occult mythos in favor of a story that can be understood entirely within the psychological symbolism of its monsters and hellish environments.

Unless he's playing it very close to the vest, Brady appears not to know anything about the plot or its major reveals, but it's a testament A: to the subtle foreshadowing the game does and B: that a therapist, appropriately enough, would pick up on the nuances of the performances to start to understand some underlying hints (though at least where I am in his playthrough, he hasn't hypothesized the truth).

Unlike him, I went into the game knowing full well the game's big twist.

But I have a lot of strong opinions on twists, and I think the best twists are always the ones that, when you re-engage with a story after seeing it the first time, feel obvious. But not only is this about twists being thoroughly foreshadowed, but also how ambiguities become far clearer with the context we gain on a second viewing.

Let's go into spoiler territory, which will include spoilers for Silent Hill 2.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Scorching Ray vs Flurry for Combos with Conjure Minor Elementals

 As far as I can tell, in my calculations of the most busted spell combination, it's really hard to beat Conjure Minor Elementals combined with Scorching Ray.

I've written about this before, but to sum up:

The 5.5 version of CME (as we'll be calling it here) doesn't summon any creatures, but instead creates an emanation around the caster out to 15 feet. The emanation creates difficult terrain for foes, but more importantly, it adds 2d8 damage (your choice of acid, cold, fire, or lightning) to each attack you land on a creature within the emanation. The damage increases by 1d8 for every level above 4th that you cast the spell at (initially as printed, it was 2d8 per spell level above 4th, and that was just impossibly powerful, so they errata'd it).

Now, the power of this is likely intended to be used with something like a Bladesinger, which gets Extra Attack, and thus gets to double-dip on this damage bonus. That makes it a good 4th level spell.

But the attacks that trigger this bonus damage need not be, like, part of the attack action. It's just "attacks," and that can include spell attacks. Now sure, a lot of spell attacks (like a Fire Bolt cantrip) are going to scale kind of unimpressively with this, because you only make a single attack as part of the spell's casting. But Scorching Ray is a spell that, at its base level, has you make three attacks, and rather than scaling up the damage of the beams it shoots as you upcast it, it instead increases the number of attacks you make.

There are a couple reasons this is good and also feels good. It feels good because it smooths out the spell - even if you miss on a beam or two, there's a pretty good chance you'll hit with one (even if the converse is true as well - even if you hit with a beam or two, there's a decent chance you'll miss with one). But what makes it more powerful because of this is, well, the way that you'll get more out of any effect that can increase the damage you deal with each attack. Much like how a Warlock gets far more value out of Agonizing Blast if they pair it with Eldritch Blast than with something like Booming Blade (yes, did you remember that Agonizing Blast actually works on any Warlock cantrip now? But why would you put it on anything other than Eldritch Blast?) Scorching Ray is going to make a spell like CME far more powerful, allowing you to potentially land 3 attacks in a turn, and only going higher as you upcast.

Now, until the WoW book came out, there haven't been really any other leveled spells that work like Scorching Ray. But we have a new one: Flurry.

A staple of the Frost Mage in WoW, its D&D equivalent functions similarly to Scorching Ray but its numbers are a little different, and it has an interesting additional effect.

Flurry is a 3rd level Evocation spell that shoots 3 shards of ice at the target. You make a spell attack for each shard, and if they hit, each deals 3d6 cold damage. If a shard crits, the target is retrained until the end of your next turn.

You then add a shard for every spell level above 3rd.

    So, to start in a vacuum:

Each spell shoots three times at its base level, but Scorching Ray is a 2nd level spell, so by the time we're comparing them, it has been upcast to 3rd level and now shoots 4.

However, even before we count the "restrain on crit" effect, Flurry is doing more damage overall - 9d6 damage versus 8d6.

That said, if we were concentrating on a base level CME, the four Scorching Ray beams would be hitting for 2d6+2d8 each, or a total of 8d6+8d8 (average of 28+36, or 64) while Flurry is doing three shards for 3d6+2d8 each, or a total of 9d6+6d8 (average of 31.5+27, or 58.5).

Now, there are a couple knobs we can adjust here: As we upcast CME, the value of more attacks grows, as every hit is hitting that much harder.

But we can also upcast Scorching Ray and Flurry as well. And, proportionately, Flurry will start to scale a little better with its damage because they're each adding an attack with each upcast, but Flurry's attacks each hit a little harder.

I think there's a world where what we need is some big spreadsheet to show at what point, and with what upcasting of CME, we wind up with better damage from Flurry.

I will note that I think you'll always be best spending the highest spell slot (or at least the highest you're willing to spend) on CME, rather than upcasting your attack spell at a higher level. Not only will CME persist through multiple spells, but I think even if you only get a single Scorching Ray/Flurry off, it's still going to be more damage if you upcast CME.

But what about the restraint imposed by Flurry?

Because our scenario above ignores that.

I don't think I'll be able to come up with a definitive answer at every spell level for both your CME and your attack spell (it's not that it isn't doable, but we'd be looking at far too many combinations of spell levels than I want to do here on a blog post - I'm sure if I were more of a wiz at Excel I could put together a function to handle it all). Cheekily, if we feel like it, we could see how insane our damage winds up being if we do a 9th level CME and an 8th level Scorching Ray/Flurry.

But for now, let's talk about the base levels (well, except upcast Scorching Ray, because a 3rd level Flurry will always beat a 2nd level Scorching Ray unless we're talking about damage resistances/immunities).

Now, I sort of wish I could do this as a kind of hit-chance agnostic thing, as crits don't really care about AC. But I'm not confident I could give a clear example that way, so we'll instead assume a 60% hit chance, which feels pretty reasonable against a boss monster (like a +9 versus an AC of 18).

Scorching Ray:

This one's really simple: we hit for 2d8+2d6 on each of four beams. Thanks to it all being dice rolls, we can just add 5% to our hit chance to account for crits, so that average damage of 16 per beam times 65% is 10.4, and then across 4 beams, we get 41.6 damage from our 3rd level Scorching Ray.

Flurry:

Prepare for the agony of a Vex-like effect.

Our first attack we'll assume is not getting advantage, so that's again our 60% plus 5% for crits of 2d8+3d6, or 19.5 average damage. That times 65% is 12.675.

Now, 95% of the time, shard #2 is going to be the same. But 5% of the time, we get advantage. This means that our hit chance is 87.75% and our crit chance is 9.75%. We can combine these into 97.5%, so that's going to be 19.0125. But, it's really 95%x12.675, rounded to around 12.04 plus 5% of 19.0125, or roughly .95, giving us a total damage of 12.99 for our second shard.

Shard # 3, though, now has a 9.75% chance for the target to have been restrained. So, 12.675x90.25% is about 11.44 and 19.0125x9.75% is about 1.85, so we get a total damage of 13.29.

Thus, our total damage here is about 38.96.

    Now, the chance we have our target restrained after all three shards shoot off has become roughly 14% - not terribly likely, but cool if it does happen and certainly good for our friends.

What happens, though, if we upcast?

We'll say we try this again when we hit 9th level, and we now have 5th level spell slots for CME and we can use 4th level spell slots for our attack spells.

4th level Scorching Ray:

Our damage is now 3d8+2d6 per beam, shooting 5 beams. So, with a 60% hit chance and 5% crit chance, our hits and our crit bonus damage are 20.5. So, 20.5x65%, so we're doing 13.325 per beam, and with five beams, we're looking at 66.625 damage.

4th level Flurry:

The method here will be to calculate our base damage, then our hit and crit chances for both no advantage and advantage, and then how likely we are to have advantage on each shard.

So, the base damage is now 3d8+3d6, or 24 average.

Once again, without advantage we have 60% hit and 5% crit, and with advantage we're looking at 87.75% hit and 9.75% crit.

So, average damage without advantage is 15.6 and average damage with advantage is 23.4.

First shard is 100% without advantage, so that's 15.6.

Second shard is 95% without, 5% with, so that's 14.82 plus 1.17, or 15.99.

Third shard is 90.25% without, 9.75% with, so that's about 14.08 plus 2.28, or 16.36

Fourth shard is about 86% without and 14% with, so that's 13.42 plus 3.28, or 16.7

Meaning at this level, Flurry gives us 64.65 damage. Still not quite catching up.

    One last time, and here I think we're likely to see Flurry overtake Scorching Ray. 

This time, we're into tier 3, and we've got one 6th level spell. We use that to get CME up and running and then cast our attack spell at 5th level.

5th level Scorching Ray:

So, we're now doing 4d8+2d6 with each of 6 rays. Again, assuming a 60% hit chance, we're looking at the average damage of 25, and then multiplying that by 65%, giving us 16.25 per beam, and with 6 beams, we're looking at 97.5 damage.

5th level Flurry:

All right, our damage is now 4d8+3d6 on each of our 5 shards. That value per hit is 28.5.

Without advantage, we're looking at 65% of 28.5, or 18.525, and with advantage, we're looking at 97.5% of 28.5, or 27.7875. For sanity, we'll round these to 18.53 and 27.79.

First shard is 100% advantage, so 18.53.

Second shard is 95% without, or 17.6 and 5% with or 1.39, total of 18.99

Third shard is 90.25% without, or 16.72, and 9.75% with, or 2.71, total of 19.43

Fourth shard is 86% without, or 15.94, and 14% with, or 3.89, total of 19.83

Fifth shard is 81% without, or 15.01 and 19% with, or 5.28, total of 20.29

Which gives this Flurry a total of 97.07 damage.

    Ok! So, that actually surprises me a little. We're still slightly behind Scorching Ray, but by less than half a point. I'd argue that at this point, though, the nearly 1-in-5 chance that we've restrained the target more than makes up for the tiny damage loss, given that it will benefit both our allies and ourselves on our next turn and keep the target locked down.

But let's take this to the extreme: What happens if we cast a 9th level CME and an 8th level attack spell?

Notably, at this point, assuming a capped spellcasting stat, we should have a +11 to hit (without any magic items to boost it), meaning to only have a 60% hit chance we'll need to be attacking something with an AC of 20. That's not unreasonable, especially given we're definitely busting this out against a boss monster of some kind (hell, the AC might be higher).

At 9th level, CME is going to add 7d8 damage to each attack that lands.

An 8th level Scorching Ray is going to be 9 beams, while an 8th level Flurry is 8 shards.

8th level Scorching Ray:

So, each beam hits for 7d8+2d6, or an average of 38.5. So, with a 60% hit chance and 5% crit chance, we're talking 25.025 damage per beam, and thus over 9 beams, that's 225.225 damage.

8th level Flurry.

Again, let's figure out damage per shard on hit - 7d8+3d6, which winds up being 42.

Without advantage, each shard is doing an average of 27.3

With advantage, each shard does an average of 40.95.

Shard 1: 27.3

Shard 2: 27.3x95% is 25.94 and 40.95x5% is 2.05, total 27.99

Shard 3: 27.3x90.25% is 24.64 and 40.95x9.75% is 3.99, total 28.63

Shard 4: 27.3x86% is 23.48 and 40.95x14% is 5.73, total 29.21

Shard 5: 27.3x81% is 22.11 and 40.95x19% is 7.78, total 29.89

Shard 6: 27.3x77% is 21.02 and 40.95x23% is 9.42, total 30.44

Shard 7: 27.3x73% is 19.93 and 40.85x27% is 11.03, total 30.96

Shard 8: 27.3x69% is 18.84 and 40.85x31% is 12.66, total 31.5

Giving our 8th level Flurry on top of a 9th level CME a total damage of 235.92 damage.

    So, we do wind up doing more with Flurry by this high level. Given that we were less than half a point off at the CME:6/SR5 level, I suspect that we would have already caught up by CME7/SR6.

There's obviously a lot of utility to being able to restrain a target, especially with an effect based on an attack roll and not a saving throw (that a boss might legendary resist out of, for example). That being said, even when you make 8 attacks in a single round, you're still less likely to have crit than not to have crit (31% versus 69%, roughly).

Now, if you have a way of somehow expanding your crit window (not a super obvious thing to achieve - off the top of my head, multiclassing with Hexblade Warlock and getting to crit on 19s with Hexblade's Curse would do it, though that now takes 3 levels of Warlock to get rather than the old 1) or otherwise guaranteeing a crit would be great ways to enhance the power of Flurry - but most things that do guarantee a crit will already be granting advantage anyway.

Restraining a target is huge, even if just for a round (I mean, a round in D&D is huge). But I also think you need to temper your expectations regarding how likely it is for Flurry to accomplish that.

Still, I think Flurry winds up being a perfectly reasonable alternative to Scorching Ray for this spell combo, and as a reasonable spell to pick up regardless. At worst, we were only around 2.5 damage behind, and I think you could argue that even with only a 14ish% chance of restraining a target, at the base level, that might make it worth it.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Weighted Chain Swashbuckler vs Wyvern

 We're doing something a little nutso here, but this is all stuff that is basically live.

With the WoW D&D book, we got an update to the Swashbuckler Rogue, acting as the option for those who want to play the equivalent of the Outlaw specialization from WoW. But this subclass makes no real concessions to WoW mechanics (which I'd argue the Spiritual Guardian does. The Mystic Brews monk does as well, but in a way I don't think anyone could ever complain about) and is a perfectly reasonable setting-agnostic subclass.

However, we also got something crazy with D&D Beyond Drops this month: a number of new weapon types, including the Weighted Chain. This is a martial, two-handed weapon, but it has the finesse property, which means that Rogues actually get proficiency with it.

And it's actually really great for them. The weapon does 1d8 bludgeoning damage on a hit, and it has the Graze property, but it also has Reach.

Now, the chain is also a Heavy weapon, meaning that, because it's a melee weapon, we will need a Strength of 13 or higher to wield it without disadvantage.

Here's the fun thing, though: with both the Heavy and Reach properties, the Weighted Chain works with... the Polearm Master feat. Yeah, it's a bit absurd, given that you generally assume a Polearm Master is fighting with... you know... a weapon that involves a pole (normally this is just the Quarterstaff, Spear, Pike, Glaive, Halberd, and Lance). But the feat technically only cares about these two properties.

Ok, so: here's how we'll imagine combining all of this:

As a Swashbuckler, we have Rakish Audacity, which means that if we're within 5 feet of a target, and there are no other creatures within 5 feet of us, we can get Sneak Attack even if we don't have advantage on our attack. Thanks to Fancy Footwork, when we attack a target, they can't make opportunity attacks against us for the rest of our turn (hit or miss).

So, what we are going to do is run up to our target, making sure we go where we're clear of foes, make our attack (and maybe make our Pole Strike bonus action attack if we don't hit the first time) and then back up ten feet, safely doing so thanks to the Fancy Footwork. Now, if the wyvern comes at us, they enter the reach of our chain, allowing us to use Reactive Strike to make an opportunity attack when they enter our reach.

Ah, I just identified a problem: technically, the Reactive Strike triggers when the target gets within our reach, which is 10 feet, but we need to be within 5 feet to get our Rakish Audacity bonus.

See, the whole point of this is to try to double up our sneak attack to do it on our turn as well as their turn. Hm... let's see.

I guess you could ask your DM if they'd allow you to hold off on the reactive strike until they get within 5 feet of you. It's a bit beyond rules as written. There, of course, might be other ways to get sneak attack - imagine for example an ally who stands within 5 feet of the target in such a way that they remain within 5 feet even when it moves toward you.

Well darn. Hm.

Eh, let's just see how much damage you can do if you somehow get Sneak Attack on both. The practicalities might become a bit more complex here, and perhaps there's some better subclass for this.

So, we'll have to take Polearm Master for one of our feats, but that's actually fine because you can boost Dexterity with it. Grabbing, say, Mage Slayer and then something like Crusher, Sentinel, Defensive Duelist - there are a lot of options. But by 10, a Rogue can have 3 General Feats, which means it'll be pretty easy to cap Dex.

While a Swashbuckler probably wants good Charisma, they're still relatively single-ability-score-dependent, so I don't think it'll break the bank to get that 13 in Strength to wield a heavy weapon.

So, capped at 20 Dex, we'll have a +9 to hit and our chain lands for 1d8+5, or 9.5. However, because it's a Graze weapon, that 5 is guaranteed.

Thanks to Polearm Master, we'll have the opportunity to make a bonus action Pole Strike attack, which is mostly good if we miss on the first attack, but still gives us a chunk of damage regardless.

Because we're able to make more than one attack, we'll calculate Sneak Attack separately. We'll assume we're using it the first time we can, so even if we crit on the Pole Strike, we only get that crit bonus on the sneak attack if we missed on the main attack. So!

Main Attack:

5 damage guaranteed. 1d8 added if we hit on a roll, but thanks to Graze, we can lump in crits. So, with a +9 to hit, we hit on a roll of 5 or higher, so that's an 80% hit chance, but then a 5% crit chance, so, 85% of 4.5 is 3.825, and then we add back in our guaranteed 5 for 8.825 damage (ignoring Sneak Attack for now) on that initial strike.

Pole Strike:

The only thing that changes here is our damage die - the Pole Strike should, in theory, still benefit from Graze. So, It's now 85% of a d4, or 2.5, so that's 2.125, plus our guaranteed 5, so that's 7.125.

Thus, from weapon attacks on their own, we are getting 15.95.

Sneak Attack:

Ok, we have the following scenarios: If we hit on the first attack, we deal 5d6 extra damage, and then an extra 5d6 if we crit. For this, we can actually just kind of do the same thing. 5d6 is 17.5 damage on average, so 85% of 17.5 is 14.875.

On the Pole Strike, if we missed on the first attack, we have that 80% + 5% crit damage. So, this is that same 14.875, but we only have a 20% chance of it happening. Thus, 2.975.

So, our total Sneak Attack damage on our turn is an extra 17.85.

And thus, our damage on our turn is a total of 33.8.

Not blowing anyone away, but now let's see how that Reactive Strike works for us.

Again, this is not something we're guaranteed to get. Indeed, a very strict reading of the Polearm Master feat and the Rakish Audacity feature would actually make them not work with one another. But if we are to assume a merciful DM (I think the fairest reading would be that the monster does need to get up within 5 ft before we can do this, but I'd allow a Polearm Master to delay their Reactive Strike the tiny moment that this would require) then we're talking about basically that initial strike along with the first iteration of our Sneak Attack (before we account for Pole Strike,) which means we're looking at 8.825 plus 14.875, giving us 23.7 more damage.

That brings our total damage per round - if we can get that Reactive Strike Sneak Attack - to 57.5.

And that is actually looking very respectable.

It's not quite there in the mid-60s of DPR we get with some of our better builds (or the insanity of the Necromancer Wizard with 15 skeletons).

The bigger issue, I think, is the dependence you have on the reaction.

How might we adjust this?

Well, I've seen people suggest multiclassing into Paladin and getting Vow of Enmity from the Oath of Vengeance. This obviously works quite well with Rogues to give them a cheap means of getting advantage. Here, I don't think the Swashbuckler is really your best option anymore, even though the Charisma will play nicely with your Paladin abilities. (We will already have the Strength necessary for Paladin given that we're using a Heavy melee weapon.)

Yeah, I don't know that this is really the best way to make use of the Weighted Chain, but it's a really fascinating weapon that bears a lot more experimentation.

Orpheus and Silent Hill 2

 I was somewhat aghast when I realized that I had come to a similar conclusion that the director of the (as far as I can tell) universally-panned Return to Silent Hill had about the story of Silent Hill 2.

The film, which I have not seen, is an adaptation of the story of Silent Hill 2 by the director who had adapted the first game's story 20 years ago. But, according to an overview I saw from Super Eyepatch Wolf, the director seemed to completely and totally misunderstand the point of the game's story, themes, and characters.

In short (though if you have the time, go check out the video,) the director seems to have very rigid views on what makes a film protagonist, what roles men and women should play in relationships, life, and stories.

Now, I don't want to linger on a movie that I haven't actually watched - while I don't have any intention of watching it, I also feel there's a certain ethical responsibility to actually see a work itself before I can render any kind of enduring judgment on it. To spare myself, I will simply note that my opinions on it are secondhand.

However, what left me somewhat aghast was the fact that the director and I both identified a mythological antecedent to the story of Silent Hill 2: the Myth of Orpheus and Eurydice. Super Eyepatch Wolf decries this comparison, though I think mainly in the context of how it aligns our sympathies.

I actually think the comparison is apt - and I even wonder if the game's writers had it in mind when writing the story.

So, for those unfamiliar:

The myth of Orpheus and Eurydice tells how the world's greatest musician, Orpheus falls in love with Eurydice and the two get married. However, when another man became infatuated with her and pursued her, she stepped on a viper, who bit her and killed her with its venom. Orpheus, in grief, sang of his lost love, impressing the nymphs and other spirits, who told him to go to the Underworld. There, he convinced Hades, to let him leave with his wife. However, Hades would allow him to take her back to the world of the living only if she followed behind him, unseen. If Orpheus were to look upon her before they reached the living world, the deal was forfeit.

Orpheus began the trek back up through the underworld, across what must have been a surreal and terrifying landscape. As he neared the cave entrance, though, a dark thought appeared in his head: that the God of the Underworld had tricked him, playing a cruel jest on him. But as he turned back to check and see if Eurydice were truly there, he found, to his horror, that she was, but by looking, he had failed in his task, and Eurydice was taken back into the Underworld, to remain there forever.

Now, I don't think that the story here is a one-to-one copy, obviously. But much as I recently mentioned that the story of Arthas Menethil in Warcraft III is a dark inversion of the story of King Arthur, complete with magic sword and elderly wizard advisor, I think we can look at the story of James Sunderland as a twisted tale of Orpheus.

And I think to see the true inversion, we need to talk about the Maria ending.

Ok, we're this far in that I feel like a spoiler tag isn't necessary: this game has been out for over two decades, and while the remake it still only a couple years old, if you've read this far, I assume you're in it for all the spoilers.

Silent Hill 2 has several endings - I want to say seven. Two are silly easter eggs that I'm sure are not meant to be viewed as canonical. But the one I'd argue is the darkest - even darker than the suicide of the In Water ending - is Maria, in which James leaves Silent Hill with the strange doppelganger of his wife, but his comment when she begins coughing suggests that he has not only learned nothing, but has maybe embraced his identity as a murderer - that Maria might become the victim of his violence now that he has abandoned any desire for repentence.

What, exactly, Silent Hill is is not something I think the games have ever been totally explicit about. Naturally, the first game makes it the home of a cult that seeks to bring about some kind of apocalyptic transformation of the world, and the monsters in the games - even those that seem drawn from characters' psyche - are probably demonic monsters of that supernatural realm. But is the town itself a portal to this Otherworld, or is it just the cult's presence there that made it like that?

Either way, the plot that James is engaged in, even if it's based on a misunderstanding of what has happened, is one where he's seemingly been promised his wife's return if he ventures into the danger of this town.

In the myth, Orpheus is punished for his skepticism: he does not trust Hades to hold up his end of the deal, and dooms Eurydice to remain dead because he cannot believe that his efforts will be rewarded.

But I think in Silent Hill 2, the town - the "god of the underworld" - is a deceiver. The promise is a false one, and the shade of his wife that James is presented with, Maria, is a false one. James' skepticism is warranted and appropriate.

Maria, and I'm not the first to suggest this, was likely created to be what James wishes his wife had been. While we only really see her in one outfit, Mary's iconic look reads "grandmother," while Maria is explicitly dressed like Christina Aguilera at a 1999 awards show. While James' sexual frustrations are certainly a part of his resentments, and are reflected in the disturbingly erotic elements of the monsters he faces, the usual interpretation is that this frustration was the result of Mary's inability have sex with him given the debilitating nature of her disease. But I also wonder if this problem was already there prior to her illness - that they were misaligned in libido.

Maria is extremely flirtatious and her words are frequently laced with innuendo. James seems deeply uncomfortable around this behavior, but is that because of his awareness of the strangeness of the situation, or is it because of his own sexual repression?

Like, let's really break this down: If Mary was always sort of sexually prudish (and I am, to be fair, basing this entirely on her choice of wardrobe, which is an admittedly thin vine from which to hang) perhaps James was also somewhat prudish himself. This is a man who we know for a fact can make himself believe things about himself that are not true, and so he might have been drawn to Mary as the kind of woman that he was supposed to like, while in his subconscious, he actually wished for her to be sexier, more aggressive, more transgressive of societal norms. (The exact setting of the game is a little up in the air, but if it's not when it first came out, it's probably in the late 80s or early 90s, meaning we're in peak social conservatism, the ascendancy of the Religious Right, and a backlash against the sexual liberation of the 60s and 70s that started with Reagan, and which was further enforced by the terror of the AIDS epidemic that psychologically linked sexual freedom to death. Even as late as 2001, when the game originally came out, the lingering social conservatism of the Reagan era was still quite strong.)

I've talked before about how the Jungian Shadow is a massive part of psychological horror, and I think that the weird thing about James Sunderland is how Maria is this sort of external reflection of his shadow - Mary was the wife he thought he wanted, but Maria was the sexual partner he actually wanted.

James comes to Silent Hill because of the impossible letter that suggests that Mary is there, somehow. He knows she's dead, even if his conscious mind has the wrong cause of death and date. So, like Orpheus, he travels to this strange place. Much like the Greek Underworld, Silent Hill is an otherworldly locale - its Fog World is kind of a liminal realm that touches both the real world and the Otherworld, but descending further, the Otherworld is a truly chthonic realm of demons.

(Hades is not really the same as the Christian idea of Hell - it's not a punishment to go there, just the place where all the dead go. Still, it wasn't a pleasant place - the vast majority of the dead, the Ancient Greeks believed, wallowed as Shades in the Underworld, aimless and wandering for eternity with faded memories. Only a select few could live in a paradise within the Elysian Fields, but Elysium was still within that same Underworld.)

So, we have a hero (and I think the Greek sense of the word hero is apt here, rather than the modern idea of a hero as a "good guy") who descends into the underworld in search of his dead wife. The god of that realm - the unseen malevolent intelligence of Silent Hill - presents James with this "shade" of Mary, aka Maria.

But what does the Maria ending of the game actually entail? It's one in which James puts aside his skepticism and doubt, accepts Maria as the thing that was promised to him, and emerges from the Underworld with her.

But whereas Orpheus successfully leaving Hades with Eurydice would have turned that myth from a tragedy into a triumph, James' "success" in this regard is deeply dark and disturbing: it is of a penance unfulfilled, a murder overlooked. Maria, even if her deeply felt purpose in existing was to get James to leave the town with her, likely only has to look forward to her own murder. Hell, given her ability to come back over and over from her, what, three deaths over the course of the game, does that mean that James is just going to murder her over and over?

The "better" endings for James are those in which he does embrace his skepticism, he does "look back" at the Shade the underworld has given him, and recognizes that this is not his wife, that the underworld gods have lied to him.

The most hopeful ending for the game, the Leave ending, shows James taking Laura out of the town. While I think it's frankly insane to think that James should adopt her, even if that's what Mary had envisioned for them, I think at the very least we could read this as James reckoning with what he did and trying to do something good with his life - even if, practically, he should find a more suitable guardian for her as soon as he gets back to civilization. (Seriously, if taking care of an ailing wife was enough to drive him to murder, maybe we don't have him raise a girl as a single dad through puberty?)

In Water is not a happy ending for the story by any stretch of the imagination. But it's one that I think is emotionally cohesive - James learns to accept what he did, what that makes him, and he decides that he can't live with being that person. Is this his escape from the truth of his murderous act, or is it some final attempt to be with the wife that he killed? It does, in fact, seem like the plan he had always had in coming to Silent Hill, and one could almost interpret the entire game as being some kind of vision before following through on his suicide... except that I do think that his interactions with Eddie and Angela were real (which also does mean that any non-Leave endings leave Laura's fate really up in the air). But while I think that suicide is the wrong choice for anyone other than a genocidal dictator, there's at least a kind of honesty to this ending that the Maria ending does not have. (I think some might view Leave as dishonest as well, though I give it a more charitable interpretation.)

One of the things that is sort of ironic about the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice is the following: while the tragic ending seems to be that Hades didn't trick him... do we know that? Did the God of the Underworld not, in fact, simply play on his human nature, and give him an impossible task? There's a kind of narrative imperative that forces the deal to fall through.

The Ancient Greeks believed fate was a force that bound even the gods. Eurydice was "doomed by the narrative," so to speak. James' journey is to recognize that his narrative is not one of a heroic widower rescuing his wife from death. The tragedy is already written, and he can only move on once he reckons with that.

I mentioned that James is a hero in the classical sense, because Greek heroes were often guilty of terrible crimes. Heracles (aka Hercules, the Roman version of his name, but I default to the Greek versions) was the greatest and most celebrated of the Mythic Heroes of the Classical Era. His most famous tale was that of the Twelve Labors, where he was assigned twelve seemingly impossible tasks. Why did he have to perform those tasks?

Well, you see, he had murdered his wife and children.

Yes, Heracles' greatest deeds were penance for an unspeakable act (yes, it was the result of madness induced by Hera, who freaking hated the guy, but the Greeks didn't really have a concept of free will, so that didn't make him any less responsible). While James and Mary didn't have any kids (thankfully,) I think we could view his killing of Mary as a similar act of madness. (The Insanity defense is far harder to prove in a real court of law than media would have you think, but might it have applied in James' case? I think you'd have to have proved that James genuinely didn't know what he was doing at the time, and the only thing we really know for certain is that he did physically smother her. His amnesia following this act would certainly imply a lot of mental distress around what he had done, but it doesn't prove that he didn't intend to kill her, and in fact, it seems quite clear he did.)

But the Greeks also didn't necessarily think that a crime like that made a character irredeemable. Heracles works through his penance by performing these great feats, and even in some tellings, achieves apotheosis.

The horror of Silent Hill 2 lies, on top of the terrifying monsters and situations, and the tragedies of Eddie and Angela (especially Angela,) in forcing us to reckon with our own weight of judgment versus our capacity for empathy toward James. At the end of the day, what is James Sunderland? He is someone who murdered his helpless wife, succumbing to his own weakness and selfishness and ending the life of the person who trusted him.

If we feel empathy for this character, who suffers from the fallout of a crime his subconscious has hidden from him, does that make us complicit? See, I think there's some fraction of the discourse around the game that seeks to give a clear, black-and-white answer, one where James Sunderland is an unmitigated monster and villain. But I think the far darker, more complicated, richer read on the game is that we are meant to empathize with him, to see the soul desperate for absolution and redemption in all of this, and to imagine that perhaps this harrowing ordeal is enough of a penance.

And then to wonder if we have sullied ourselves by stooping to forgive a murderer.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

A Look at Frostmourne in D&D

 Probably the most iconic weapon out of the Warcraft franchise, wielded by the most iconic villain, who is also the highest-CR monster in the WoW D&D book, Frostmourne carries with it a certain caché. Ironically, though, the story is not nearly as complex or extensive as that of its opposite number, the Ashbringer (which I covered in the previous post).

It was only during the very controversial Shadowlands expansion (I say controversial - it might be better to say it was unpopular, though I maintain it is not the worst expansion, and was certainly better than Warlords of Draenor and possibly its predecessor, Battle for Azeroth) that we got hints as to the deeper history of Frostmourne.

Let's talk about the original lore, which will be quite quick, and then we can do the Shadowlands stuff (which is mentioned in the book).

So, when Arthas pursued the Dreadlord Mal'ganis to the frigid continent of Northrend, he struggled to slay the demon in a permanent (or at least longterm) manner. He had happened across his old dwarven friend Muradin Bronzebeard, one of King Magni's younger brothers. Muradin, pursuing the dwarven fascination with archaeology, had found stories about a powerful magic sword, and Arthas thought that this might be the key to defeating his demonic foe.

However, upon finding the blade, Muradin read a warning that had been left there: anyone who took up the blade would lose their very soul. Arthas, in an act of reckless wrath, shrugged off this curse and took up the blade. The tremors that followed from this act of doom would knock out Muradin with falling rubble, and the newly soulless Arthas left his friend for dead, keen on getting his revenge.

Claiming victory against Mal'ganis, Arthas returned to Lordaeron to a hero's welcome, but the sword had done its work - unbeknownst to the celebrating crowds in Lordaeron City, along with Arthas' father King Terenas, Arthas had not only become corrupted himself, but dragged his own forces into undeath with the power of the sword. Arthas stabbed his father through the neck with the blade, and began a massacre of the capital city, spreading the undead Scourge across the kingdom that he had technically just inherited as the new king.

The blade, it turned out, had come sealed away in the Frozen Throne along with the Lich King.

The original Lich King had been the soul of the Orc shaman Ner'zhul, who had originally been tricked by the demon Kil'jaeden into forming the Horde in its murderous original incarnation. Ner'zhul, seeing the Horde defeated in the Second War, fled back to Draenor, and used artifacts looted on Azeroth to open numerous portals to other worlds. The stresses tore the planet apart, leaving the surreal landscape of Outland behind, and Ner'zhul found himself captured by Kil'jaeden the moment he stepped through his chosen portal.

Kil'jaeden tortured Ner'zhul, tearing his soul from his body, and sealed it into a suit of armor. He then froze that armor and the blade Frostmourne into the icy crystal that would become the Frozen Throne, which he hurled toward Azeroth. It landed in Northrend, and from there, Ner'zhul worked to build an army of the dead on behalf of the demonic Burning Legion.

The blade bound Arthas' will to that of the Lich King, and removed all inhibitions from his latent sociopathic tendencies. While he furthered the Legion's plans during the Third War, he also secretly worked to undermine them, the Lich King's ultimate goal to break away from the Legion's control.

Arthas would go on to defend the Lich King even after the Third War from forces the Legion sent to wrest back control of the Scourge, and upon his victory, he ascended to the Frozen Throne and used Frostmourne to break the armor of the Lich King out of the crystal. Taking the Helm of Domination, the capstone of the Lich King armor, onto his own head, he merged with Ner'zhul, ultimately absorbing the Shaman and becoming the dominant will within the Lich King.

He actually spent several years frozen back into the Frozen Throne, commanding the Scourge mentally from his seat, and Frostmourne went unused during this time. But when his grand plan - to provoke the Alliance and Horde into sending him their greatest champions so that he could raise them as his own, he emerged from the Frozen Throne and took on a more active role leading the Scourge in person.

Frostmourne remained his weapon during this time, but when the final battle came to its culmination, as he sought to raise the greatest heroes of Azeroth as his own personal agents, Tirion Fordring, wielding the Ashbringer, shattered Frostmourne, leading to Arthas' demise and the defeat of the Scourge.

However, the shards of Frostmourne remained - later, during the last full-scale invasion by the Burning Legion, some Death Knights traveled to retrieve these shards, and had them reforged into a pair of shortswords called the Blades of the Fallen Prince (the artifact weapon for Frost Death Knights during Legion).

Now, you'll note that there's basically no actual explanation of where the blade even came from (and some questions, like how there were already myths and legends about Frostmourne that Muradin was chasing down when the sword could have only gotten to Northrend, like, a year or two earlier at most).

In the Shadowlands expansion, it was revealed that while Kil'jaeden had played an active role in the creation of the Lich King, the actual source of power behind the Scourge was not demonic/fel in nature, but was the power of the Shadowlands - Warcraft's realm of death (which includes the afterlives).

Frostmourne was actually one of a handful of Mournblades, which were created on behalf of the Jailer - an incredibly powerful entity of the Shadowlands whose malevolence saw him locked away in the ultimate planar Oubliette, the Maw - almost precisely Warcraft's version of a dark, bleak, cold hell.

The Jailer, with help from his prisoner, the Primus (a being of comparable power in the Shadowlands) produced the blades and the Helm of Domination as part of his plan to sweep over all of creation and bring every living thing under his direct control, like a master puppeteer for the entire cosmos. This power of domination is at the heart of evil necromancy, and was the primary tool of the Jailer.

So:

Given the lore - that the sword claims the souls of any who take it up or who are slain by it - you might think... this is probably not the safest weapon to wield. And you'd be right.

It's also one of two artifacts that are listed directly as equipment on the Lich King Arthas stat block (the other being the Helm of Domination). While the Helm does actually give you a chance to retain your free will if you put it on (much as Bolvar Fordragon, who became the Lich King after Arthas, did, and used his powers to hold back and weaken the Scourge,) Frostmourne doesn't work that way.

Upon attuning to the sword, you become Undead (if you weren't already) and your alignment becomes Neutral Evil (if it wasn't already). These changes remain in place even if you end your attunement.

    Now, I think there's a debate to be had as to whether Arthas was already evil before he took up the blade, or if he was still Lawful Good but had just taken his convictions to an extreme that accomplished evil despite his intentions (it's a very dark thing to debate, but his infamous Culling of Stratholme... might that actually have been the right call, horrific as it was?)

Also, while attuned to the sword, the Lich King can see through your eyes and hear through your ears, and communicate telepathically with you regardless of distance, even across planes.

    So, this raises an interesting question: if you slay Arthas and get this, who is the Lich King? In theory, it's whoever then loots the Helm of Domination. While I won't do the whole stats for that, attuning requires a DC 18 Charisma saving throw to avoid having your mind absorbed by the Lich King. Bolvar, who was probably a 20th-level paladin in D&D terms, might have had as much as a +15 to such saves (with Aura of Protection,) so it makes sense that he'd be able to succeed.

Ok, now the core things:

Frostmourne is a +3 Greatsword. It does 2d12 extra Cold damage on a hit. If you reduce a creature to 0 HP, the creature dies and its soul is trapped in the sword. While trapped, the target cannot be raised from the dead until Frostmourne is destroyed.

    I'd assume "raised from the dead" means specifically resurrection magic, as you sure as hell can be raised as undead. That's kind of the Lich King's whole thing.

Now, while anyone can attune to Frostmourne, Paladins get additional benefits (interesting question: do we count Death Knight here? I think the precedent we have is that Doomhammer, a famous Shaman weapon - actually the Enhancement Shaman artifact in Legion - requires attunement by a Barbarian, not a "Shaman," so I'd say Paladin here includes Death Knights - which only makes sense). First off, Undead creatures of your choice (excluding you) in your Aura of Protection have advantage on attack rolls and saving throws. Then, also, all allies in your aura gain immunity to Cold damage.

    I'd actually strongly consider integrating that second part into Arthas' stat block, as he has some powerful AoE abilities that would theoretically hit his undead allies and do frost damage.

Beyond that (oh, was that all?) there's 1 major beneficial property, 1 minor detrimental property, and 1 major detrimental property.

    Major detrimental properties can be very nasty - the 97-100 one prevents you from regaining HP, for example.

Finally, Frostmourne can be destroyed if its wielder is slain by someone wielding the Ashbringer, and only the Runecarver (er, spoilers: aka the Primus) can reforge it from the fragments.

    So:

    Two things:

    First off, chances are that if you have gotten Frostmourne, you've done it by defeating Arthas, which means that you're probably at the end of your campaign. Arthas is built as a campaign end-boss, and while I'd argue that on the strict "tiers of play" guidance, he really ought to be a tier 3 boss (as he's a global, rather than multiversal threat) I also get that he's the most popular Warcraft villain and they want him to be super powerful. (I'd argue that expansion final bosses who do warrant tier 4 are probably Kil'jaeden, Archimonde, Argus, the Jailer, and Dimensius the All-Devouring, and possibly N'zoth and C'thun (the latter of which retroactively became the final boss of Vanilla because of Naxxramas' relocation to Northrend)).

    Technically you don't become an NPC under the DM's control, but you might want to talk about what it means for your character to become Neutral Evil. While you can certainly have an evil team player in a party, the narrative of Frostmourne is that you don't just turn evil, but become a villainous antagonist to the party.

    It is cool that we get this weapon statted out. But at the same time, I just don't think it would be practical to ever have a player use it in a campaign - unless you want the finale of a campaign to be the rest of the party fighting against the one who has just attuned to it. Or, if you're playing a villainous campaign, sure, maybe then.

A Look at The Ashbringer in D&D

 The Ashbringer was a fabled weapon introduced in World of Warcraft - without any precedence in the older games like Frostmourne or Doomhammer. Its history is pretty interesting:

The final raid of "Vanilla" World of Warcraft (as the game's original era prior to the release of its first expansion, The Burning Crusade, was called) was Naxxramas, a massive floating ziggurat that served as the base of operations for Kel'thuzad, the lich who had started Arthas on his path of corruption and, in undeath, was basically his chief advisor. (The premise of Arthas' story in WCIII was meant to be a kind of villainous inversion of King Arthur, where a young man finds a powerful sword and is guided by a magical advisor, so in this case, Kel'thuzad is basically evil Merlin).

Naxxramas was infamously only even entered by a small fraction of players. I believe still the largest raid in WoW to date, it had 15 bosses, with four wings that functioned almost like shorter, 3 or 4-boss raids branching off from a central hub. Defeating the final boss of each wing unlocked the upper level, where you could fight the Frostwyrm (think Dracolich) Sapphiron and then Kel'thuzad, both of whom were established in Warcraft III (or the Frozen Throne expansion in the case of Sapphiron).

The final boss fight of the Military Quarter, generally seen as the third wing (they sort of ramped up in difficulty, though you could do them in any order) was the Four Horsemen, a quartet of death knights (obviously inspired by the Book of Revelations).

Leading the Four Horsemen, at least in the original version of the raid, was Alexandros Mograine. Mograine had been a great champion of the Holy Light, and fell not because of his own corruption, but because of his treacherous son Renault (who is one of the bosses in the Scarlet Monastery and appears in the book,) who murdered his father, allowing him to be raised as a Death Knight of the Scourge.

While fabled as the hardest raid of Vanilla WoW (though that also might have been simply because it was the one that required the best gear, expecting you to have gone through the other, earlier raids,) it was brought back as the first major raid in Wrath of the Lich King, ironically becoming famous as probably the easiest raid in WoW's history, though this also meant it was a great place for new raiders (like myself) to get the hang of it. However, in the new version, Alexandros was replaced by Baron Rivendare (who had been a boss in the Stratholme Dungeon, over which Naxxramas had originally hovered), for reasons that will become clear below.

(The raid clearly had to be redesigned a little bit to accommodate the smaller raid sizes in Wrath - going from 40 players in Vanilla to a 10-player and 25-player mode in Wrath - but I also wonder if its relative ease was just that, only two expansions into WoW, raid bosses were mostly becoming far more complex, and Naxx's 2005-era design was far simpler. Having never set foot in the original version of the raid, which was removed when they relocated it to Northrend for Wrath, I can't really comment on how similar or different the fights had been.)

The elder Mograine had earned the epithet "The Ashbringer" because of power he wielded through his sword of the same name. The sword itself had been built around a strange crystal that was recovered from Orc Warlocks during the Second War. This crystal had been suffused with shadowy, dark magic, but while Mograine and his fellow paladins tried to destroy the crystal with a bombardment of holy magic, it instead purified the crystal.

The crystal was taken to Magni Bronzebeard, king of the Bronzebeard clan and a peerless blacksmith (kind of a big part of dwarven culture when your capital city is built around a massive forge). He crafted a greatsword that the crystal would sort of hover magically within as part of the blade.

For years fighting the Scourge, Mograine channeled the light so powerfully through this sword that when he struck the undead, they would sometimes be instantly disintegrated into ash - hence the name.

However, with his son's betrayal, the sword itself was corrupted, cycling back into a state of darkness.

Players could get this Corrupted Ashbringer as a drop off the Four Horsemen boss fight in Vanilla. You could actually take it into the Scarlet Cathedral dungeon and confront Renault with it (by this point you'd be so much higher level that you could safely wade into the dungeon without fear) and the Scarlet Crusaders, in reverence for the blade of the Ashbringer, would bow down to you. The spirit of Alexandros would emerge and slay his murderous son.

But the Ashbringer remained corrupted. For years, there were rumors and speculation about whether there was a hidden sequence of things you could do to purify the weapon. They turned out to be false.

However, in the backstory prior to the events of Wrath of the Lich King, Alexandros' other son, Darion, sought out the Ashbringer so he could free his father from this cycle of undeath. Plunging the sword through his own chest (which is crazy given how enormous that blade is) he gave up his life so that his father would be free, but then was raised himself as a Death Knight.

Darion was (probably) the first of a new order of Death Knights, the Knights of the Ebon Blade, who struck a massive blow against the Scarlet Crusade, and then were turned to fight against the (actual good guys) Argent Dawn. Drawing out the elder paladin Tirion Fordring (one of the founding members of the Knights of the Silver Hand,) the Lich King revealed he had sent the Ebon Blade to attack the Argent Dawn as cannon fodder, to be slain to draw out Fordring. Realizing he had been betrayed, Darion threw the corrupted Ashbringer to Tirion, and in this act of redemption, the blade was purified, and the Lich King was turned back at the Battle of Light's Hope Chapel, while Tirion offered to vouch for the Death Knights who had turned on the Scourge, sending them on a path to redemption and reconciliation with their people.

Tirion would go on to wield the Ashbringer in the war against the Lich King. Accompanying the "heroes of Azeroth" (aka the players) to the top of Icecrown Citadel, the Lich King immediately froze Fordring in a block of ice to keep him from joining the fight. Once the fight had gone on long enough, Arthas immediately unleashed a lethal wave of necrotic energy, slaying all the heroes who had come to fight him, and began to raise them as his new champions. But Tirion, protected by his icy prison, called upon the light to give him the strength to escape his bonds, and, breaking free, leapt up and shattered Frostmourne with the Ashbringer.

With the wicked sword destroyed and the souls trapped within it freed (including whatever was left of Arthas',) the spirit of King Terenas (Arthas' father, whom he murdered) emerged, reviving the heroes, and together, they finished off Arthas.

For years, Tirion remained the holder of Ashbringer. However, when the Burning Legion invaded, and he led the Argent Dawn (well, Argent Crusade - I prefer the Dawn as the name of the organization, which changed in Wrath) to fight the demons, he was overwhelmed and seemingly killed. However, the Knights of the Silver Hand, recently reformed and integrating the various paladin orders across different cultures of Azeroth, found that he had been captured instead. While the demonic captor was slain, Tirion had sustained fatal injuries, and to the paladin who defeated the demon, he bestowed the Ashbringer.

Functionally, the Legion expansion gave each specialization its own unique artifact weapon, which you'd keep the whole expansion and simply upgrade to higher power rather than getting new weapons. The Ashbringer was the artifact weapon for Retribution paladins.

Hilariously enough, each artifact weapon had several variant appearances you could unlock, including a secret one with methods of attaining it that varied from weapon to weapon. You could get a "corrupted" appearance for the Ashbringer that required you to do many of the things that people had speculated you would need to do to purify the old Corrupted Ashbringer from Naxxramas.

Anyway, it has become one of the most beloved and iconic weapons in WoW, so I'm not surprised that it's in the book. It's also deeply tied into the story of the Scourge, which is probably the most popular villain faction.

Now: in D&D, artifacts are generally not meant to be permanent magic items for a PC to have. It's not a hard and fast rule, of course, but I think that handing this to a player might be something you do for a particularly climactic event - maybe the player earns the right to carry it into battle against the Lich King, for example (though if they get the killing blow, that means you won't get Frostmourne - which is maybe for the best).

Ashbringer is an artifact greatsword, which requires attunement by a paladin.

It has a +3 bonus to attack and damage rolls. It also deals 1d10 extra fire damage on a hit, which goes up to 3d10 fire damage when hitting an undead creature.

    I think the Adz of Annam does hit harder - it's a greataxe that does an extra 3d12 force damage. But certainly against undead, this is among the hardest-hitting weapons you can get. And while 1d10 isn't that crazy, adding a damage die to any weapon is a pretty big upgrade.

Ashbringer can be found in one of two states - True State or Corrupted State. An act of legendary wickedness will turn it from True form to Corrupted, and an act of legendary heroism will turn it back from Corrupted to True.

Each form has a different feature:

Steal Life, which is the corrupted version, will give you 20 Temp HP when you reduce a creature to 0 HP.

Wake of Ashes, which is the true version, will make a target expode into a cloud of ash when you reduce it to 0 HP (you can choose whether to do this or not). Each creature of your choice within 10-foot emanation originating from the target must make a DC 18 Con save or be Blinded until the end of its next turn.

    Each form certainly has its uses. I think that, given that you probably aren't going to get this weapon until quite high levels, I'd probably say the Wake of Ashes one is more likely to be useful, as you might have other sources of Temp HP that give you more. That said, 20 is still a significant chunk of THP even at high levels.

Ashbringer is sentient, with an Intelligence of 14, Wisdom of 17, and Charisma of 17. It's lawful good in its true state and lawful evil when corrupted. It also has 120 feet of darkvision. It can communicate with its wielder telepathically and speaks Common and Dwarven.

    This is interesting - the weapon has never demonstrated sentience in WoW, and there certainly are weapons that have, like a certain dagger whose former inhabitant is the main villain in WoW's current story arc. That said, there's long been a theory that the crystal around which the sword is built is a fragment of a Naaru, the crystalline light-beings who can go through a cycle of light and void.

    I will also point out that in the WoW book, true to WoW, Horde characters actually don't learn Common. Orcish is the "Common" of the Horde (there's even an Orcish sign language in the book). Now, does it make sense that Forsaken can't speak Common? Not really. Also, while these languages are used in the MMO to make a language barrier between the factions, given how often important NPCs interact in a friendly way with both factions, either they're all multi-lingual or it's just sort of a convention. But in theory, you might have foreign words going into your brain if you're, say, a Tauren Paladin (or "Sunwalker.") 

Ashbringer has 1 minor beneficial property, 1 major beneficial property, and 1 minor detrimental property.

    I don't know that I love the random properties thing with artifacts, but at least there's no major detriment. Still, some minor detriments can be pretty bad, like giving you disadvantage on Strength and Con checks and saves. 

Finally, if for some bizarre reason, you want to destroy the sword, you can actually just bring it to Magni, who made the sword and can unmake it just the same. Despite the legend surrounding the Ashbringer, the sword is not some ancient relic, and its creator is an active political leader within his society (he did spend some years as a diamond, but that's a whole other story).

    All in all, the Ashbringer is actually a pretty straightforward magic item. It's obviously good - it deals more damage than a Holy Avenger unless you're fighting a fiend (Holy Avenger gets its bonus 2d10 against undead and fiends, while Ashbringer gets 1d10 always and then an extra 2d10 against undead) though its on-kill effect might not be as great as the Holy Avenger's Aura of Protection upgrade.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

A Look at Illidan Stormrage from the WoW D&D Book

 Illidan Stormrage is the most emo character in Warcraft lore.

For D&D fans, and more specifically those who are fans of (maybe even discovered D&D through) Critical Role, you'll know the voice of Illidan quite well, as within WoW, he's voiced by Liam O'Brien (though not in his original appearance in Warcraft III). Indeed, most of the folks from CR have done voices for prominent characters, like Laura Bailey playing Jaina Proudmoore (who also has a very high-CR stat block, though she's more likely to be an ally than a foe... except for a period from Mists of Pandaria through Battle for Azeroth if you're Horde).

Anyway, I'll start off this look at the stat block with a quibble: the book lists Illidan's alignment as Neutral Evil, and I just must take strong objection to that. Illidan is a profoundly reckless person who has used dangerous and forbidden magic to defeat the foes that threaten his world, and I think this makes him very, very clearly a Chaotic Neutral character. He's too ruthless to be good-aligned, but he's also somewhat selfless in his motivations (in other words, I'd say he leans more good than evil, though some of his methods have been quite bad).

I think I've already gone through his backstory like twice on this blog, so let's instead talk about his appearances in the Warcraft games.

In WCIII, he had been imprisoned for ten thousand years following the War of the Ancients (like all Night Elves, he had benefited from the immortality granted to them by the World Tree Nordrassil) but was released by Tyrande Whisperwind, his childhood friend and the object of his deeply toxic love triangle with his twin brother Malfurion. Illidan, having infiltrated the demon-sympathetic forces of Queen Azshara during the War of the Ancients, was the ideal expert to help fend off this next invasion, though his release required the killing of several Night Elf Wardens by their own Priestess of Elune (put a pin in that).

Illidan led some of the Night Elf forces against the Burning Legion in a region called Felwood, but struggled to defeat the Dreadlord Tichondrius because of the Dreadlords' particularly fast resurrection (all demons simply go back to the Twisting Nether when slain, but Dreadlords seem to have some faster turnaround... ok, I can't get distracted by the whole bizarre and deeply retconned lore of the Dreadlords). Helpfully, the then-Death Knight Arthas Menethil showed up and presented Illidan with a solution: if he took the Skull of Gul'dan (the profoundly evil Orc Warlock who had been the secret power behind the Old Horde) and consumed the Fel magic within it, he would have what he needed to defeat Tichondrius in the long term (later on, in WoW, Tichondrius came back, but it was several years later, rather than just a couple minutes like in that battle).

Illidan secured the skull, but the energies transformed him into a half-demon himself. He slew Tichondrius, but then, you know, had a new problem with his PR amongst his people.

In the Frozen Throne expansion for WCIII, Illidan had fled into exile, going to the shattered remnants of the Orc homeworld of Draenor, where he sought to build a kind of cult/kingdom for himself. Gathering Naga, Blood Elf, and Broken ("Krokul") Draenei to his cause, he set himself up in the Black Temple, once the main holy Temple of Karabor built by the Draenei on the planet when they arrived a thousand years prior.

However, Kil'jaeden, one of the two primary lieutenants of Sargeras and essentially the "Left Hand" of the Burning Legion, found Illidan and threatened to destroy him and all of his followers unless Illidan would do him a solid and destroy the Lich King, who had rebelled agains the Legion.

Illidan launched an assault on the Scourge back on Azeroth with his followers, conjuring an earthquake that cracked the Frozen Throne (and thus freed the Forsaken from the Lich King's domination, though this was an unintended side effect) and then traveled to Northrend to assault Icecrown, where the Frozen Throne had landed.

However, while the siege was a massive battle between the Illidari and the Scourge, ultimately it was Arthas who emerged victorious, defeated Illidan in a one-on-one duel. Arthas would go on to ascend the Frozen Throne and merge with the Lich King, his will coming to dominate that of Ner'zhul's and become among Azeroth's greatest villains.

But Illidan survived his battle and retreated with his surviving forces to Outland, where he worked to shore up his defenses in the event of Kil'jaeden's inevitable assault upon him.

However, his efforts to control Outland put him in conflict with the forces of the Naaru, the Alliance and Horde expeditions there, and his callous debauchery within the Black Temple had even lost him the loyalty of Akama, the Krokul leader of the Ashtongue Deathsworn, the mutated Draenei priests who had once worshipped in Karabor's halls. Akama, working with adventurers and freeing the leader of the Wardens, Maiev Shadowsong, struck back against Illidan at the summit of the temple, killing him all while Illidan had sent his Illidari Demon Hunter trainees on a mission.

Illidan's body was locked away in a crystal for years, but when the Legion invaded again (in the Legion expansion,) the demons attacked the Vault where Illidan's body was being kept, stealing it away and attempting to use his body as a vessel for Sargeras to enter Azeroth.

However, adventurers (perhaps even some of the same who had slain him nine years prior) freed him from this prison, the fel magic resurrecting him but not having a chance to make him a vessel.

Illidan, at this point, saw his purpose more clearly, and became an important ally in the fight against the Legion once again. Using a magical crystal (the objective of his Demon Hunter proteges years before,) he opened a portal from Azeroth to Argus, the world that was effectively the Legion's main base of operations (home to the Eredar, including the Draenei).

During the invasion of Argus, the Prime Naaru (still not totally clear what that means compared to a regular Naaru) X'era declared that Illidan had a cosmic destiny, and sought to forcibly purge his fel magic and replace it with the Holy Light. But Illidan refused, destroying X'era for violating his body autonomy. (The Draenei Prophet Velen, who was a witness to this, sealed my impression of him as a truly good person because he saw this and seemed to find Illidan's actions totally reasonable, even though Velen is a devout adherent of the Light. Consent, people. It's a hard line.)

Fighting through the corrupted Titan facility of Antorus, the adventurers battled against the newborn Titan Argus, whom Sargeras had corrupted over the eons while he was just an embryonic Worldsoul, and with Argus' defeat, the remaining members of the Titan pantheon were able to draw Sargeras back into their cosmic throne, the Seat of the Pantheon, where Illidan remained along with the Titans to battle Sargeras for... eternity, as far as we can tell.

So: Illidan is really more of an antihero than a villain, and while he certainly did some unprincipled and bad things, his motives, to me, have mostly been for the greater good (or sometimes to save his own skin). I don't think he wants anyone to suffer unless they're bad guys.

But all that aside: it's not unthinkable that you'd come into conflict with him. I imagine that the stat block here is imagining him in that Burning Crusade-era version of him at the Black Temple (and certainly that's reflected in some of the abilities he has.

Phew, all that preamble aside: what's his stat block like?

Illidan is a CR 24 Large Fiend. This puts him as the second-highest-CR stat block in the book, just after Arthas (makes sense, as Arthas did beat him a duel). He's fast - a 60 foot walking and flying speed, and he's got a decently hefty HP pool at 430 and an AC of 20.

True to the Demon Hunter working as a Ranger, his best stats are Dex and Wisdom. Also, appropriately enough, he has 120 feet of Blindsight - the Fel magic in his burned-out eye sockets giving him sight beyond sight (...was going to say something about a certain very influential science-fiction series but don't want to spoil an upcoming movie for those who haven't read the books).

Illidan has something approximating a Mythic mode, where he gains a new trait, a new action and a new legendary action, which he can activate once he's bloodied.

Complementing his high movement, opportunity attacks against him are made with disadvantage. He also has your standard legendary resistance and magic resistance.

Bizarrely, he isn't listed as carrying the Warglaives of Azzinoth, given that those are his iconic weapons (and are in the book as a pair of artifact scimitars). He has a somewhat simple multiattack - making one Flame Crash - a ranged/melee ability that deals 22 fire damage and has a +14 to hit - and then two Warglaive attacks (18 slashing and 19 force, also with a +14 to hit).

His legendary actions have a once-per-round Agonizing Flames, which forces a dex save against a single target, dealing 33 fire damage and then making them burn for 1d12, or a save for half of the main damage only. Then, Strike lets him move up to half his speed and do a Flame Crash or Warglaive attack.

When bloodied, once a day, he can use a bonus action to unleash the Demon Within (basically his version of the spell Metamorphosis,) which regains him 100 HP and then unlocks three new things:

Aura of Dread triggers a Con save of 22 from anyone within 30 feet of him, dealing 19 necrotic damage on a failure and, also on a failure, preventing them from regaining HP until the end of their next turn.

Shadow Blast is part of his actions that can take the place of the Flame Crash attack in his multiattack that is basically a 30-foot radius necrotic fireball with a Dex save of 22.

Finally, Draw Soul forces a target he can see ("see") within 60 feet, dealing 45 force on a failure, and insta-killing them if they hit 0 HP from it, though only once per round.

And that's more or less it other than some skills and such.

    So, I think running Illidan is very straightforward. Most of his damage is coming from his Warglaives, so you can't have him just stay out of melee range (though he does have a 10-foot reach with the Warglaives). I think his high speed and the disadvantage on opportunity attacks against him does mean he's suited for hit-and-run tactics. He should be pretty good at focusing down vulnerable party members.

I will say, though, that the simplicity of his stat block actually makes him a pretty great choice for an allied NPC. While he's so high-CR that you'll need to make some really hefty encounters for the party to need that much help, it would be fitting with his characterization in most of his appearances (Burning Crusade having been a time when some players complained that he had been thrown the "villain ball.") Also fitting to that characterization, though, is that the Aura of Dread would also harm allies.

While I for sure never fought Illidan when he was a current raid boss (I went into Karazhan, BC's first raid, like twice during that expansion, and that was the extent of my raiding experience prior to Wrath of the Lich King) I do know that there was a phase where he flew up into the air and his glaives manifested two giant fel fire elementals that I think you needed to take down at the same time. There's no real equivalent thing here, though I do think that the Warglaives of Azzinoth can summon fire elementals. (Actually, upon checking, they instead let you cast Summon Fiend with the devil option).

Anyway, Illidan is certainly one of the most iconic characters in Warcraft lore, and one who could very easily play either ally or antagonist in a campaign.