As far as I can tell, in my calculations of the most busted spell combination, it's really hard to beat Conjure Minor Elementals combined with Scorching Ray.
I've written about this before, but to sum up:
The 5.5 version of CME (as we'll be calling it here) doesn't summon any creatures, but instead creates an emanation around the caster out to 15 feet. The emanation creates difficult terrain for foes, but more importantly, it adds 2d8 damage (your choice of acid, cold, fire, or lightning) to each attack you land on a creature within the emanation. The damage increases by 1d8 for every level above 4th that you cast the spell at (initially as printed, it was 2d8 per spell level above 4th, and that was just impossibly powerful, so they errata'd it).
Now, the power of this is likely intended to be used with something like a Bladesinger, which gets Extra Attack, and thus gets to double-dip on this damage bonus. That makes it a good 4th level spell.
But the attacks that trigger this bonus damage need not be, like, part of the attack action. It's just "attacks," and that can include spell attacks. Now sure, a lot of spell attacks (like a Fire Bolt cantrip) are going to scale kind of unimpressively with this, because you only make a single attack as part of the spell's casting. But Scorching Ray is a spell that, at its base level, has you make three attacks, and rather than scaling up the damage of the beams it shoots as you upcast it, it instead increases the number of attacks you make.
There are a couple reasons this is good and also feels good. It feels good because it smooths out the spell - even if you miss on a beam or two, there's a pretty good chance you'll hit with one (even if the converse is true as well - even if you hit with a beam or two, there's a decent chance you'll miss with one). But what makes it more powerful because of this is, well, the way that you'll get more out of any effect that can increase the damage you deal with each attack. Much like how a Warlock gets far more value out of Agonizing Blast if they pair it with Eldritch Blast than with something like Booming Blade (yes, did you remember that Agonizing Blast actually works on any Warlock cantrip now? But why would you put it on anything other than Eldritch Blast?) Scorching Ray is going to make a spell like CME far more powerful, allowing you to potentially land 3 attacks in a turn, and only going higher as you upcast.
Now, until the WoW book came out, there haven't been really any other leveled spells that work like Scorching Ray. But we have a new one: Flurry.
A staple of the Frost Mage in WoW, its D&D equivalent functions similarly to Scorching Ray but its numbers are a little different, and it has an interesting additional effect.
Flurry is a 3rd level Evocation spell that shoots 3 shards of ice at the target. You make a spell attack for each shard, and if they hit, each deals 3d6 cold damage. If a shard crits, the target is retrained until the end of your next turn.
You then add a shard for every spell level above 3rd.
So, to start in a vacuum:
Each spell shoots three times at its base level, but Scorching Ray is a 2nd level spell, so by the time we're comparing them, it has been upcast to 3rd level and now shoots 4.
However, even before we count the "restrain on crit" effect, Flurry is doing more damage overall - 9d6 damage versus 8d6.
That said, if we were concentrating on a base level CME, the four Scorching Ray beams would be hitting for 2d6+2d8 each, or a total of 8d6+8d8 (average of 28+36, or 64) while Flurry is doing three shards for 3d6+2d8 each, or a total of 9d6+6d8 (average of 31.5+27, or 58.5).
Now, there are a couple knobs we can adjust here: As we upcast CME, the value of more attacks grows, as every hit is hitting that much harder.
But we can also upcast Scorching Ray and Flurry as well. And, proportionately, Flurry will start to scale a little better with its damage because they're each adding an attack with each upcast, but Flurry's attacks each hit a little harder.
I think there's a world where what we need is some big spreadsheet to show at what point, and with what upcasting of CME, we wind up with better damage from Flurry.
I will note that I think you'll always be best spending the highest spell slot (or at least the highest you're willing to spend) on CME, rather than upcasting your attack spell at a higher level. Not only will CME persist through multiple spells, but I think even if you only get a single Scorching Ray/Flurry off, it's still going to be more damage if you upcast CME.
But what about the restraint imposed by Flurry?
Because our scenario above ignores that.
I don't think I'll be able to come up with a definitive answer at every spell level for both your CME and your attack spell (it's not that it isn't doable, but we'd be looking at far too many combinations of spell levels than I want to do here on a blog post - I'm sure if I were more of a wiz at Excel I could put together a function to handle it all). Cheekily, if we feel like it, we could see how insane our damage winds up being if we do a 9th level CME and an 8th level Scorching Ray/Flurry.
But for now, let's talk about the base levels (well, except upcast Scorching Ray, because a 3rd level Flurry will always beat a 2nd level Scorching Ray unless we're talking about damage resistances/immunities).
Now, I sort of wish I could do this as a kind of hit-chance agnostic thing, as crits don't really care about AC. But I'm not confident I could give a clear example that way, so we'll instead assume a 60% hit chance, which feels pretty reasonable against a boss monster (like a +9 versus an AC of 18).
Scorching Ray:
This one's really simple: we hit for 2d8+2d6 on each of four beams. Thanks to it all being dice rolls, we can just add 5% to our hit chance to account for crits, so that average damage of 16 per beam times 65% is 10.4, and then across 4 beams, we get 41.6 damage from our 3rd level Scorching Ray.
Flurry:
Prepare for the agony of a Vex-like effect.
Our first attack we'll assume is not getting advantage, so that's again our 60% plus 5% for crits of 2d8+3d6, or 19.5 average damage. That times 65% is 12.675.
Now, 95% of the time, shard #2 is going to be the same. But 5% of the time, we get advantage. This means that our hit chance is 87.75% and our crit chance is 9.75%. We can combine these into 97.5%, so that's going to be 19.0125. But, it's really 95%x12.675, rounded to around 12.04 plus 5% of 19.0125, or roughly .95, giving us a total damage of 12.99 for our second shard.
Shard # 3, though, now has a 9.75% chance for the target to have been restrained. So, 12.675x90.25% is about 11.44 and 19.0125x9.75% is about 1.85, so we get a total damage of 13.29.
Thus, our total damage here is about 38.96.
Now, the chance we have our target restrained after all three shards shoot off has become roughly 14% - not terribly likely, but cool if it does happen and certainly good for our friends.
What happens, though, if we upcast?
We'll say we try this again when we hit 9th level, and we now have 5th level spell slots for CME and we can use 4th level spell slots for our attack spells.
4th level Scorching Ray:
Our damage is now 3d8+2d6 per beam, shooting 5 beams. So, with a 60% hit chance and 5% crit chance, our hits and our crit bonus damage are 20.5. So, 20.5x65%, so we're doing 13.325 per beam, and with five beams, we're looking at 66.625 damage.
4th level Flurry:
The method here will be to calculate our base damage, then our hit and crit chances for both no advantage and advantage, and then how likely we are to have advantage on each shard.
So, the base damage is now 3d8+3d6, or 24 average.
Once again, without advantage we have 60% hit and 5% crit, and with advantage we're looking at 87.75% hit and 9.75% crit.
So, average damage without advantage is 15.6 and average damage with advantage is 23.4.
First shard is 100% without advantage, so that's 15.6.
Second shard is 95% without, 5% with, so that's 14.82 plus 1.17, or 15.99.
Third shard is 90.25% without, 9.75% with, so that's about 14.08 plus 2.28, or 16.36
Fourth shard is about 86% without and 14% with, so that's 13.42 plus 3.28, or 16.7
Meaning at this level, Flurry gives us 64.65 damage. Still not quite catching up.
One last time, and here I think we're likely to see Flurry overtake Scorching Ray.
This time, we're into tier 3, and we've got one 6th level spell. We use that to get CME up and running and then cast our attack spell at 5th level.
5th level Scorching Ray:
So, we're now doing 4d8+2d6 with each of 6 rays. Again, assuming a 60% hit chance, we're looking at the average damage of 25, and then multiplying that by 65%, giving us 16.25 per beam, and with 6 beams, we're looking at 97.5 damage.
5th level Flurry:
All right, our damage is now 4d8+3d6 on each of our 5 shards. That value per hit is 28.5.
Without advantage, we're looking at 65% of 28.5, or 18.525, and with advantage, we're looking at 97.5% of 28.5, or 27.7875. For sanity, we'll round these to 18.53 and 27.79.
First shard is 100% advantage, so 18.53.
Second shard is 95% without, or 17.6 and 5% with or 1.39, total of 18.99
Third shard is 90.25% without, or 16.72, and 9.75% with, or 2.71, total of 19.43
Fourth shard is 86% without, or 15.94, and 14% with, or 3.89, total of 19.83
Fifth shard is 81% without, or 15.01 and 19% with, or 5.28, total of 20.29
Which gives this Flurry a total of 97.07 damage.
Ok! So, that actually surprises me a little. We're still slightly behind Scorching Ray, but by less than half a point. I'd argue that at this point, though, the nearly 1-in-5 chance that we've restrained the target more than makes up for the tiny damage loss, given that it will benefit both our allies and ourselves on our next turn and keep the target locked down.
But let's take this to the extreme: What happens if we cast a 9th level CME and an 8th level attack spell?
Notably, at this point, assuming a capped spellcasting stat, we should have a +11 to hit (without any magic items to boost it), meaning to only have a 60% hit chance we'll need to be attacking something with an AC of 20. That's not unreasonable, especially given we're definitely busting this out against a boss monster of some kind (hell, the AC might be higher).
At 9th level, CME is going to add 7d8 damage to each attack that lands.
An 8th level Scorching Ray is going to be 9 beams, while an 8th level Flurry is 8 shards.
8th level Scorching Ray:
So, each beam hits for 7d8+2d6, or an average of 38.5. So, with a 60% hit chance and 5% crit chance, we're talking 25.025 damage per beam, and thus over 9 beams, that's 225.225 damage.
8th level Flurry.
Again, let's figure out damage per shard on hit - 7d8+3d6, which winds up being 42.
Without advantage, each shard is doing an average of 27.3
With advantage, each shard does an average of 40.95.
Shard 1: 27.3
Shard 2: 27.3x95% is 25.94 and 40.95x5% is 2.05, total 27.99
Shard 3: 27.3x90.25% is 24.64 and 40.95x9.75% is 3.99, total 28.63
Shard 4: 27.3x86% is 23.48 and 40.95x14% is 5.73, total 29.21
Shard 5: 27.3x81% is 22.11 and 40.95x19% is 7.78, total 29.89
Shard 6: 27.3x77% is 21.02 and 40.95x23% is 9.42, total 30.44
Shard 7: 27.3x73% is 19.93 and 40.85x27% is 11.03, total 30.96
Shard 8: 27.3x69% is 18.84 and 40.85x31% is 12.66, total 31.5
Giving our 8th level Flurry on top of a 9th level CME a total damage of 235.92 damage.
So, we do wind up doing more with Flurry by this high level. Given that we were less than half a point off at the CME:6/SR5 level, I suspect that we would have already caught up by CME7/SR6.
There's obviously a lot of utility to being able to restrain a target, especially with an effect based on an attack roll and not a saving throw (that a boss might legendary resist out of, for example). That being said, even when you make 8 attacks in a single round, you're still less likely to have crit than not to have crit (31% versus 69%, roughly).
Now, if you have a way of somehow expanding your crit window (not a super obvious thing to achieve - off the top of my head, multiclassing with Hexblade Warlock and getting to crit on 19s with Hexblade's Curse would do it, though that now takes 3 levels of Warlock to get rather than the old 1) or otherwise guaranteeing a crit would be great ways to enhance the power of Flurry - but most things that do guarantee a crit will already be granting advantage anyway.
Restraining a target is huge, even if just for a round (I mean, a round in D&D is huge). But I also think you need to temper your expectations regarding how likely it is for Flurry to accomplish that.
Still, I think Flurry winds up being a perfectly reasonable alternative to Scorching Ray for this spell combo, and as a reasonable spell to pick up regardless. At worst, we were only around 2.5 damage behind, and I think you could argue that even with only a 14ish% chance of restraining a target, at the base level, that might make it worth it.
No comments:
Post a Comment